3 Sisters win £1.6m Inheritance Battle against ‘Entitled’ Brother

Three sisters have won a bitter inheritance battle against their brother over their millionaire father’s £1.6m fortune.

3 Sisters win £1.6m Inheritance Battle against 'Entitled' Brother f

"Sonny was an extremely poor witness"

Three sisters have won a bitter £1.6 million inheritance dispute against their brother after accusing him of trying to claim a larger share of their millionaire father’s fortune, including the family’s gold bars and jewellery.

A judge ruled that £300,000 held in their late father’s bank account belonged to his estate and should be shared between his children, while also rejecting the brother’s claim that he had been gifted the contents of a safety deposit box in India.

Hari Grover died aged 85 in September 2024 without leaving a will.

His estate in England was initially valued at around £865,000 for probate, including his home in Ealing, while a collection of gold bars and jewellery held in a safety deposit box in India was estimated to be worth up to £500,000.

His only son, Sonny Grover, was appointed administrator of the estate.

However, his three sisters, Airan Grover-Jones, Kiran Cotterell and Kelly Puri, took legal action against him, claiming their father had intended for his fortune to be divided equally between his children.

The sisters argued that the value of their father’s estate in England was closer to £1.15 million, accusing their brother of wrongly claiming ownership of £300,000 in savings and the gold and jewellery held in India.

Their lawyers alleged that Sonny had “misappropriated money and the other property” belonging to the estate by failing to include hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of assets that should have been shared with his sisters.

However, representing himself at Mayors and City County Court, Sonny maintained that the money in his father’s bank account had passed directly to him because he had been made a joint account holder years before his death.

He also insisted that his father had gifted him the gold and jewellery, along with control of the safety deposit box, in 2017.

In his ruling, Judge Nicholas Parfitt criticised Sonny’s conduct during the proceedings, describing him as an “extremely poor witness” who was “constantly argumentative”.

The judge said the family had initially got on following Hari’s death but “began to disagree and fell out” when dealing with inheritance tax forms.

Sonny subsequently took “unilateral” steps to administer the estate, further deepening the family dispute.

The judge said: “Sonny was an extremely poor witness because he was simply constantly argumentative.

“He is essentially seeing this case as an argument between him and his sisters and as long as he can keep swinging he is in the game.

“Unfortunately, that is not the way the court makes decisions. It seeks to establish what the facts are from the documents that are made available and the recollections of the witnesses.”

Despite his criticism, Judge Parfitt said there was “no criticism of the work done [by Sonny] on the estate outside of the relevant items…he has done a good job”.

However, he concluded that Sonny believed “a just result in this case is one which would see him getting everything and his sisters getting nothing, because that’s what he deserves”.

The dispute over the £300,000 in savings centred on Sonny’s argument that the account had passed to him automatically through the right of survivorship after his father made him a joint holder eight years before his death.

He claimed his father had “attended a branch and executed a formal mandate” to make the arrangement and that he had also contributed some money to the account.

Sonny further argued that the bank had told him the funds did not need to be included in the estate.

However, the judge rejected his claim, making clear that the bank’s position did not determine who legally owned the money.

He said: “It is the court, not the bank, that decides this dispute, surprisingly enough.

“I’m not persuaded that any part of the funds in the account at the date of death had been sourced from Sonny’s assets.”

“This is the account in which his father’s life savings were held,” said the judge, adding that he had heard evidence that Hari kept his passbook to the account “secret” and wrapped up hidden in his clothes.

The judge concluded: “That is indicative that the father kept this account to himself. I don’t think he involved Sonny at all.”

Judge Parfitt ruled that Sonny was not a “beneficial” joint holder of the account when his father died, meaning the £300,000 would form part of the estate and be available for distribution between the siblings.

The judge also rejected Sonny’s claim that he had been gifted the contents of the safety deposit box in India.

He said Hari had told his daughters shortly before his death:

“Don’t worry, you can trust your brother; he will share things equally.”

The judge said this indicated that although Hari had handed Sonny control of the box in 2017, he had not intended to give him sole ownership of everything inside it.

He found there was “uncertainty about the contents of the box” and ruled that Hari had “entrusted the box to [Sonny] rather than gifted it.

Sonny must now provide “an account” of the contents of the box when he was given control of it in 2017, allowing the family to establish what it contained and how the items should be distributed.

The judge also addressed the question of whether Sonny should be removed as administrator of his father’s estate.

Rather than immediately replacing him, he allowed him to remain in the role for a further six months, giving the family a “final opportunity for the parties to cooperate.”

During that period, Sonny must not make any “unilateral” decisions about the estate’s assets and must notify his sisters before taking any action. He must also comply with the court’s orders.

The judge said the family needed to decide whether the gold collection should be broken up and distributed between the current generation or whether certain items should be returned to those who owned them.

Sonny was also ordered to pay his sisters’ legal costs, estimated at £80,000, from his share of the estate. A separate application for an immediate payment towards those costs was stayed for six months.

Lead Editor Dhiren is our news and content editor who loves all things football. He also has a passion for gaming and watching films. His motto is to "Live life one day at a time".





  • Play DESIblitz Games
  • What's New

    MORE

    "Quoted"

  • Polls

    Which outfit would you wear for the big day?

    View Results

    Loading ...
  • Share to...